Dan Nelson · Chicago 2 to 4 unit buildings
Only when three things are all true: your credit score is too low for a regular loan, you can't come up with the extra 1.5% down, and you only want a 2-flat (a building with two apartments). If even one of those isn't true, the regular loan with 5% down usually serves you better. Here is why.
An FHA loan is a home loan backed by the federal government. You still get it from a regular lender. It lets you buy a building with up to four units with 3.5% down, as long as you live in one of them.
Less money down. On a $500,000 2-flat, 3.5% down is $17,500. The regular loan (lenders call it a conventional loan) at 5% down is $25,000. That is $7,500 less to bring when you buy.
Easier on credit. FHA takes lower credit scores than most regular loans. With a score of 580 or higher, you can put 3.5% down.
Mortgage insurance for the life of the loan. Mortgage insurance is a fee that protects the lender. Put less than 10% down and you pay FHA mortgage insurance until you sell or replace the loan with a new one: a fee when you buy, usually added to the loan, plus a monthly charge. On the regular loan, mortgage insurance comes off once you own enough of the building.
A weaker offer. Many sellers would rather take an offer with a regular loan, because FHA's check of the building can mean repairs and delays. Some listings say up front they won't take FHA offers. When several buyers want the same building, an FHA buyer may have to offer a lot more to win it.
A building that has to pass. The lender sends an appraiser, the person who checks what the building is worth. On FHA, the appraiser also checks that the building meets the government's standards for safety and condition, and that every unit is a legal unit. Repairs the appraiser calls for usually have to be done before the sale can close, and a building that needs a lot of work can have a hard time getting approved.
On a building with 3 or 4 units, FHA adds a rent test. The appraiser sets what each unit would rent for today, including the one you live in. The lender counts only 75% of that total. That number has to cover the whole monthly payment: the loan, taxes, insurance and mortgage insurance. Put simply, with only 3.5% down, the building has to pay its own way as if you did not live there, with a quarter of the rent left out. Very few Chicago 3-flats and 4-flats pass this test, so in practice FHA is a 2-flat loan here.
Pick FHA only if all three are true:
If any one of those isn't true, the regular 5% down loan is usually the better choice. It makes a stronger offer, and its mortgage insurance comes off as you pay the loan down or the building goes up in value. A lender can run both on the same building for you.
Want the full picture first? See is house hacking worth it in Chicago and how little you can put down on a 2-flat.
Want help picking? Our team will walk you through both loans on a real building.